Southern Chess Pie is a basic dessert that brings a wealthy, gooey custard filling with a touch of caramelized goodness on prime. Fortunately, this pie is tremendous straightforward to make. This recipe requires a pie crust and just some extra components that you just most likely have already got readily available, so that you’ll have the ability to whip up this pie very quickly in any respect! It has such a deliciously candy and distinctive taste that everybody might be begging you for the recipe!
For easier pie recipes, attempt our Straightforward Peasy Pumpkin Pie or our Previous Normal Strawberry Pie.
Why Our Recipe
- The proper gooey custard filling that’s wealthy and candy with cornmeal to supply texture.
- A caramelized layer on prime supplies the right end.
- Tremendous easy to make in order that anybody from newcomers to pie professionals can get pleasure from.
Southern chess pie is nice, indulgent, and downright scrumptious! The filling is just like custard, however the cornmeal provides it extra texture than custard. The sugar caramelizes on prime of the pie because it bakes, making it even yummier. A superb comparability is the flavour of pecan pie in the event you simply eliminated the pecans!
Ingredient Notes

- Pie Crust: This recipe doesn’t stroll you thru the way to make a pie crust, however don’t have any concern! We now have our Idiot Proof Pie Crust recipe that we swear by. In the event you’re in a pinch, you need to use a store-bought pie crust, however simply make certain you don’t skip the freezing step on this recipe! In any other case, your crust gained’t obtain that good texture because it bakes.
- Cornmeal: This small quantity of cornmeal within the recipe is essential to the normal taste and texture of chess pie.
- Milk: Complete milk works greatest, however you’ll be able to at all times use 2%.
- Lemon Juice: You need to use bottled lemon juice for this recipe if you need, however contemporary is at all times greatest. The lemon juice cuts by way of the sweetness of the pie, giving it a extra advanced taste.
Recipe Origins
Chess pie has been round for a very long time—some say it originated again in England within the 18th century! It’s not clear the place precisely the title chess pie got here from, however not one of the theories counsel that it’s named after the sport of chess. Some sources say that one baker of this pie served it saying, “It’s simply pie,” however her Southern accent made the phrase “simply” sound like “chess.”
Others say that the title refers back to the chests that folks used to retailer their meals in to maintain it contemporary, and that it was as soon as once more misunderstood and became “chess pie” somewhat than “chest pie.” We’d not know why it was ever deemed chess pie, however we do know one factor—it’s nonetheless a superbly scrumptious dessert!

Forestall Cracking
In the event you transfer this pie out of the oven too quick, you’ll be able to threat cracking the highest! One approach to stop pies from cracking is to put the pie dish on a cookie sheet earlier than placing it within the oven. That may make it a lot simpler to take out of the oven, and also you additionally gained’t have to fret about spills in your oven!
Serving Options
You may at all times serve slices of chess pie plain, however you can too gown them up with slightly one thing further. Giving the pie a dusting of powdered sugar on prime is the simplest approach to glam it up. And, after all, pie is at all times nice served with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream. If you wish to get fancier, you’ll be able to prime with contemporary berries or add slightly orange or lemon zest on prime.
Storage Directions
Retailer at room temperature by protecting the pie loosely with plastic wrap or foil for as much as 2 days.
Refrigerate leftovers in an hermetic container or coated with plastic wrap or foil for as much as 5 days.
Freeze particular person slices then wrap tightly in plastic wrap and place in a resealable freezer bag. Retailer within the freezer for as much as 2 months. Thaw within the fridge earlier than serving.
Watch the video under the place Caytlin will stroll you thru each step of this recipe. Generally it helps to have a visible, and we’ve at all times received you coated with our cooking present. Yow will discover the entire assortment of recipes on YouTube, our Fb Web page, or proper right here on our web site with their corresponding recipes.
